By devoting all its energies to creating an inclusive romantic comedy in all respects, Fire Island seems to have neglected an essential element: humor.
Let's get one thing clear first: no, Fire Island is not a bad movie. We even spend a pleasant moment during its 100 minutes. The problem ? All memories seem to evaporate as soon as the credits roll.
This new comedy, landed on Disney a few days ago, transports us straight to Fire Island, the favorite destination of the LGBT community located off New York. It is on this mythical island that a group of friends will experience an eventful week with a series of events and situations echoing those of Pride and Prejudice, a Jane Austen classic here reviewed through a prism in the colors of the 'Rainbow.
Worn stereotypes
Fire Island's premise, like its trailer, foreshadowed a biting, caustic, and irreverent comedy. A male and queer Bridesmaids, what. But the reality is quite different. The humor there could not be more classic, even cheesy. We hardly laugh at these easy gags based too often on clichés and hackneyed stereotypes, without the slightest finesse.
Luckily the cast manages to save the day with their contagious energy and undeniable charm. We feel a real chemistry between Bowen Yang, Joel Kim Booster (also screenwriter) and Conrad Ricamora, something that allows us to keep an interest in these predictable love affairs. If not funny, it's endearing. Better than nothing.
It is therefore with a vague aftertaste of disappointment that we leave this Fire Island which is struggling to fulfill its promises. Fans of the genre will (hopefully!) have better luck with Bros, another queer romantic comedy expected to hit our screens next September.