The Super Bowl’s long history of unexpected heroes

ATLANTA – Maybe it’ll be Tom Brady who makes the biggest play of Super Bowl XLI on Sunday. It could happen. Stars – specifically, star quarterbacks – have been known to rise to the occasion in the biggest game. Joe Namath did. Brett Favre did. Joe...

The Super Bowl’s long history of unexpected heroes

ATLANTA – Maybe it’ll be Tom Brady who makes the biggest play of Super Bowl XLI on Sunday. It could happen. Stars – specifically, star quarterbacks – have been known to rise to the occasion in the biggest game. Joe Namath did. Brett Favre did. Joe Montana did time and time again. So did Roger Staubach and Terry Bradshaw.

Maybe it’ll be Julio Jones, who is the breakout star of this Super Bowl week that is admittedly quiet and muted by most standards of Super Bowl week. The two-week pause between games has allowed a vast appreciation for Jones’ gifts to grow, and it would surprise nobody if Jones had the kind of eye-popping impact Lynn Swann used to regularly bring to Super Bowls, the way Jerry Rice did, the way Larry Fitzgerald did in his only shot at The Game.

“I wanted to make sure that the rest of my life, whenever I look back at this game, I know I gave my very best,” Swann said after Super Bowl X, the one where he made about three of the most ridiculous catches anyone has ever made. “I think I did that.”

Here’s the thing, though:

What’s just as likely to happen is this: a guy you’ve paid zero attention to – maybe even a guy you’ve still never heard of – is going to make a play on Sunday at NRG Stadium. He’s going to make an absurd interception (hello, Malcolm Butler!) or make a catch that defies six different laws of physics (good to see you again, David Tyree), or make a game-saving tackle one yard shy of the end zone on the game’s final play, the way the Rams’ Mike Jones did against Tennessee’s Kevin Dyson in Super Bowl XXXIV.

And really, that’s the beauty of the Super Bowl: when the forgotten names rise to the fore and perform as nobody could have expected. And there have been few Super Bowls that hold such promise as this one does, because aside from Brady and Jones and Matt Ryan and a couple of others scattered across both rosters, these are teams comprised of grinders who fill their roles and fill them well. And one of them is going to have America talking about him Monday morning.

And it won’t stop there. Heck, the Super Bowl has been delivering these stories from the start. For years Bart Starr has told the story of walking down to the hotel lobby around 7 o’clock on the morning of Super Bowl I and running into Max McGee – only McGee wasn’t looking for a newspaper, he was returning from a night out on the town.

McGee barely played that year. But when Boyd Dowler was hurt, he went in the game and caught two touchdown passes. He lived another 40 years after that game; rare was the day he wasn’t asked to recall that story. He never much minded.

Jack Squirek was a little-known linebacker with the Los Angeles Raiders until 12 seconds remained in the first half of Super Bowl XVIII. That’s when he sniffed out a Joe Theismann screen pass, returned it for a touchdown, and became one of the unlikeliest of all Super Bowl impact players, his name an automatic to be included in every Super Bowl trivia show conducted at every sports-talk-radio show in America every year.

“I never thought back then that people would still remember me,” Squirek told Sports Illustrated 27 years later. “They don’t recognize me by face, but my name rings a bell with some folks, and probably 20-30 times a year someone says something. It’s always nice.”

He’s out there. Somewhere. On Sunday morning of Super Bowl V, Jim O’Brien was a rookie placekicker that many of his Baltimore Colts teammates derisively called “Lassie” because of his shaggy hair and care-free spirit; by Sunday night those teammates were mobbing him for booting the first game-winning field goal in Super Bowl history, affording many of them a mulligan for Super Bowl III.

On the morning of Super Bowl XXII, Timmy Smith was an unknown Washington rookie running back who had gained a total of 126 yards in his career; by Sunday night, he’d chewed up the Broncos for 204 yards and two touchdowns. Sometimes you bring your star to the Super Bowl. And sometimes a star finds you.

Our editors found this article on this site using Google and regenerated it for our readers.

NEXT NEWS